|
Since April 1998, the VV Project has solicited
feedback from various agencies to see how they use their own e-mail
group or newsgroups to interact with their volunteers. In addition,
CompuMentor, San Jose Children's
Musical Theater, LibertyNet, Boulder Community Net and the American
Lung
Association have been generous enough to let the VV Project
staff join their lists and observe first hand how they are used to
interact with volunteers.
In all cases, these lists are used by the
volunteer manager to communicate volunteer opportunities and/or
updates for the volunteers. Some
of the groups do not allow volunteers to post
to
the list; it's an announcement/update vehicle, not a discussion group.
Others do allow volunteers to use the list to post, ask questions of
each other, etc.
There are pros and cons to both approaches. Any
list, for volunteers or otherwise, can get out of control with
off-topic posts. Ways to solve this is to
remind off-topic posters about the purpose of the list,
create
a moderator function where all posts must be approved before
they are posted, or, eliminate the ability of all but the volunteer manager
to post altogether.
Some organizations have said they won't allow
volunteers to post because of privacy issues -- they are
very protective of the e-mail addresses of their volunteers.
Some
agencies have said they fear someone posting something confidential or
negative about the organization to all the other volunteers. (more information about confidentiality
in online programs).
On the other hand, allowing volunteers to ask
questions of each other is a marvelous way to create a sense of
community among volunteers, and promotes the idea of just how important
their work is to the organization. Volunteers often help
each
other (and the volunteer manager) with various issues, and volunteers
seem to really value hearing suggestions from other volunteers -- the people who
have "been there."
A good example of an online discussion group
for volunteers is PCORPS-L (which is gatewayed to the newsgroup
bit.org.peace-corps). This is for people who have served or who are
interested in
serving in the Peace Corps. It is not sponsored
by
the Peace Corps itself, however, and they have no control
over what someone says about the program on this list. Discussions on this
list have included:
Keys to the
Success of List for Volunteers
The key to
creating and maintaining a successful list for volunteers is to
determine a mission/reason for the list, and express this mission clearly
and effectively to potential participants. Why is this list
necessary
for your volunteers? What do you want the volunteers to
value about the list? What do you want to happen as a result
of the list?
A
successful list also takes more than participants -- you will also need people
filling these roles:
VOLUNTEERS CAN FILL ALL OF THESE
ROLES. Just as with any task, match volunteers to roles based on their
experience and interest.
The list owner must make incentives obvious and
valuable to increase and maintain volunteers' motivation to
participate. Some groups require all
volunteers to subscribe to a list. In addition, some
groups
also emphasize a sense of responsibility in members to post,
making it part of their volunteer commitment, to maintain a certain level of
participation in lists.
Other suggestions:
For more suggestions, visit The Moderator's
Home Page, Resources for Moderators and Facilitators of Online
Discussion, at http://jan.ucc.nau.edu/~mpc3/moderators.html.
This is a growing set of resources, mostly
scholarly, for moderators of online discussions, including chats, listservs
and
newsgroups. This is an extensive bibliography of netiquette guides, sample
editorial policies, using online discussion groups in classrooms, tips for moderating, and information
on teaching online.
Reprinted with permission from the
Virtual Volunteering Project, http://www.serviceleader.org/vv/
part of the Charles A. Dana Center, at the University of Texas
at Austin. Visit this valuable site for the
latest update on this subject.
|